Chris asks if the Roman Senate moved with the capital to Constantinople.
Constantine wanted his city to copy Rome in nearly every respect. Rome had 7 hills so Constantinople would too- even if it took some creative counting to reach seven on the Bosporus. He naturally intended for a Senate as well- not to replace the Roman one but to mirror it. But despite Constantine’s best effort, Constantinople’s version of the Senate was much less respected and originally functioned as a kind of city magistrate. As the importance of the city grew so did its Senate’s prestige.
Although power shifted decisively east in the 4th and 5th centuries, the two bodies- Roman and Constantinopolitan- existed side by side for a surprisingly long time. In the West the Senate outlasted the empire by several centuries. They continued to meet and pass legislation (mostly pertaining to city affairs) after the last emperor was put out to pasture in 476. Theodoric consulted them when he took possession of the city and Justinian officially restored some of their ancient privileges in the sixth century. There are records of them acclaiming eastern emperors until the seventh century and although they probably stopped meeting as a group sometime after that, senatorial families were still powerful in Medieval Italy. (The Orsini family for example claimed to be descended from the Julio-Claudians- a member of their clan was raised to the papal throne as late as the 18th century)
In the East, the Senate remained as a functioning body until the 13th century. Their last recorded act was raising the unfortunate Nicholaus Kanabus as emperor during the 4th Crusade. Their power had been declining for centuries (as detailed here) and their titles were empty, but there were Senators defending Constantinople’s walls on the morning of May 29, 1453.
It’s the morning after an election and as luck would have it Shane asks a political question- what did the Senate do other than enrich itself and plot?
Aristotle first observed that ‘man is a political animal’ and as far as senators go that animal hasn’t changed in more than 2,000 years.
From the beginning Byzantine senators were lured east by the perks- free grain and land at the state’s expense. There were relatively few duties to get in the way of enjoying the good life. While the Roman Empire held on to the conceit that it was a Republic long after any trace of representative government had vanished- as late as the 6th century it was still issuing coins proclaiming the Republic- actual responsibilities were few and far between. There was an obscure clause in one of Justinian’s law codes that said any new law had to be discussed by the Senate, but it was never enforced. Their sole administrative duty was to manage the spending of money on the exhibition of games or public works. This was not a highly lucrative job, so most senators (there were 2,000 of them) used the office for tax reasons- namely to escape the fees levied on others. (the more things change…)
Of course the Senate never quite forgot its august history and there were sporadic attempts to grasp real power. In 532 they participated in the Nika Riots hoping to replace Justinian with one of their own members. (Justinian repaid them by confiscating the Senate House and turning it into a reception hall for the Great Palace.) In 608 they elected Heraclius as Consul, then elevated him to emperor against the usurper Phocas. On his deathbed in 641, Heraclius thanked them by entrusting his young son Heraklonas to their care. The Senate promptly deposed the boy and replaced him with a grandson of Heraclius named Constans II. For the next three years the empire was openly ruled by the Senate- the first time since the assassination of Julius Caesar in 44 BC.
That turned out to be the swan song of senatorial ambition. After Constans came of age their importance quickly declined. The Macedonian emperors stripped them of most of their remaining duties and the Senate was turned into a glorified imperial court. Ordinary criminals were given a jury of 5 senators chosen by lot, while high treason involved the whole body. There was still a whiff of prestige attached to the name, but Alexius Comnenus did away with that by allowing anyone to purchase senatorial rank directly from the emperor.
Their last known act was to elect a man named Nicholaus Kanabus as emperor in opposition to the pathetic Isaac II during the fourth Crusade. Nicholaus- a gentle man- immediately fled to the Hagia Sophia and refused to come out. But his resistance to the imperial summons failed to save him. Another man seized control of the government, and as a warning to any challengers had Nicholaus dragged out of the church and strangled.